Tesla Deemed Liable for Fraud Over $110,000 Solar Roof That Never Powered Home

A California judge imposed an issue sanction after Tesla repeatedly failed to produce evidence, while damages and the company’s appeal remain unresolved

Elon Musk’s Tesla faces Solar Roof fraud ruling
A California judge deemed Elon Musk’s Tesla liable for fraud as a pretrial sanction in a dispute over an unfinished Solar Roof that supplied no electricity to the homeowner Steve Jurvetson / Wikimedia Commons / CC-BY-2.0

A California judge has deemed Tesla liable for fraud and negligent misrepresentation over a $110,000 (£83,300) Solar Roof that never supplied electricity to a homeowner's house. The 11 September 2026 ruling followed Tesla's repeated failures to produce evidence in a civil lawsuit.

Judge Cynthia Freeland imposed an issue sanction, establishing liability on both claims without a trial on their merits.

Tesla disputes the order and is seeking appellate relief, while damages remain undecided and the case has not reached final judgment.

What Happened to the Solar Roof

Ambrose Conroy of Rancho Santa Fe signed a March 2020 contract for a 13.1-kilowatt Solar Roof costing $82,210 (£62,200).

Two amendments expanded it to an 18.2-kilowatt system with six Powerwall batteries, bringing the price to approximately $110,000 (£83,300) by February 2021.

The roof remained unfinished, never passed county inspection and never supplied power to Conroy's home, according to court records reviewed by Electrek. In February 2025, Tesla attended another inspection without plans for the roof's ventilation system.

Conroy's electrical expert examined wiring beneath the tiles and warned that it could cause short circuits and fire during heavy rain. Tesla's lawyers disputed that assessment, which has not been independently established.

Conroy estimates repairs to his damaged property will cost well over $2.5 million (£1.89 million). That is his estimate, not a court award, while Tesla reportedly offered $5,000 (£3,785) to settle in April 2022.

How Tesla Became Liable for Fraud

Conroy sued in 2022, but disputes over discovery, the pretrial exchange of evidence, repeatedly delayed the case. In February and June 2026, Freeland imposed financial sanctions after Tesla failed to produce required documents and an adequate log of material it considered privileged.

The missing material reportedly included Microsoft Teams messages, communications with county inspectors and more than 20 internal quality, installation and safety reports. After Tesla missed another deadline, Freeland imposed the more severe issue sanction on 11 September.

That sanction treats liability for fraud and negligent misrepresentation as established for trial. It does not mean a jury evaluated the claims and returned a fraud verdict, nor does it constitute a criminal conviction.

Freeland also found evidence of wilful conduct in Tesla's failure to disclose records. That finding concerned Tesla's handling of evidence, rather than a separate determination after a trial on the merits about its original representations to Conroy.

Tesla Challenges the Ruling

In a joint trial-readiness report filed on 20 October, Tesla accepted liability for breach of contract, breach of warranty and negligence. However, it continued to challenge the fraud and negligent misrepresentation sanction.

Tesla argued it had supplied the requested records and the disclosure dispute was unrelated to fraud. Freeland rejected reconsideration on 27 October, saying late documents could support Conroy's allegation that his home had been used as an installation experiment.

On 29 October, Tesla requested a pause while seeking intervention from the California Court of Appeal. It argued the sanction was excessively punitive and violated due process, while the planned 20 November trial was removed.

A trial-readiness conference is scheduled for 4 December, but the appellate challenge's outcome remains unverified. Unless the sanction changes, the remaining fraud-related issues concern compensation and whether punitive damages should be awarded.