AI Job Interviews Are Putting Applicants Off, With Some Ready To Walk Away Before Getting Hired

A UK survey finds 11.2% would probably or definitely withdraw if their first interview were conducted by AI

man taking a call on laptop
In a Careerminds survey, 22.2% of baby boomers aged 62–64 said they would probably or definitely withdraw from an application over an AI-led first interview Vitaly Gariev/Pexels

More than one in 10 UK full-time workers say they would probably or definitely withdraw an application if their first job interview were conducted by AI rather than a person. The finding puts a concrete risk behind employers' recruitment decisions: some prospective candidates say the interview format alone could be enough to make them leave.

The survey by workforce services provider Careerminds asked 1,000 UK full-time workers through Pollfish in October and was published on 2 November. Its 11.2% withdrawal figure measures hypothetical intentions, not applicants observed abandoning recruitment.

That total comprises 5.7% who probably would withdraw and 5.5% who definitely would, so it should not be read as a group uniformly committed to leaving.

Continuing Does Not Mean Feeling Comfortable

An AI interview would not stop most respondents outright, but continuing does not necessarily mean approval. Another 33.4% say they would proceed while feeling uncomfortable, while 24.5% would base their decision on the role or salary.

For employers, those responses distinguish willingness to participate from enthusiasm about the process: an application can remain active despite reservations.

For AI interview practice, the provider advises checking the format and rehearsing relevant examples. It does not assess whether an AI interview assistant improves performance. That preparation advice concerns navigating the process, rather than demonstrating that a particular tool improves an applicant's chances.

Applicants Are Assessing the Employer Too

James, a 29-year-old from North West London whom the provider spoke to, describes how that distinction can play out. Approached on LinkedIn about an operations executive role, he initially thought the opportunity was a strong fit.

His first-stage AI job interview, however, offered no chance to ask questions about the company or position. He said it 'felt like a one-way process' and left him questioning the employer's approach to recruitment.

His account illustrates a problem beyond answering questions successfully: candidates also need information to decide whether they want to work somewhere. It does not establish that he withdrew.

Separate research from recruitment software provider Greenhouse extends the communication issue beyond the interview itself. Its survey reports that 42% of UK candidates who completed an AI interview never heard back.

That is a reported follow-up experience, not evidence that AI caused the silence, but it identifies another point where applicants receive no information.

Better Hiring Outcomes Answer a Different Question

AI interviewing can nevertheless produce better results in a defined setting. A study described by Chicago Booth Review randomly assigned about 70,000 candidates for customer-service roles to AI or human interviews.

Those interviewed by AI were more likely to receive offers, start work and remain employed, without a reported productivity decline. Candidates knew AI was involved, and human recruiters reviewed interview material and made the final hiring decisions.

Those findings concern hiring outcomes in that recruitment arrangement, rather than whether UK workers welcome every automated interview. Disclosure and human review describe the experiment; they are not independently established explanations for its results.

A process that helps employers select candidates still has another audience to satisfy. In James's account, the company collected his answers while leaving his questions unanswered, weakening his interest before a hiring decision had been reached.