
A woman who spent £750 on an iPhone from British electronics retailer Currys was left stunned after receiving a dummy handset instead of the Apple smartphone she had ordered. Even more astonishingly, she received the exact same handset after returning it twice, meaning it was delivered to her three times.
The customer, identified as Lucy, eventually recovered her money through her bank after Currys refused to issue a refund, according to a BBC Watchdog investigation reported by The Times of India.
Her experience was among several cases uncovered by the BBC investigation, which raised concerns about a wider pattern of retail fraud involving expensive electronics.
Woman Gets Same Fake iPhone Three Times
Lucy bought the iPhone for £750 from Currys' Carlisle store. However, when the package arrived, it contained a dummy handset rather than the genuine Apple device.
She contacted the retailer and arranged to return the item, expecting the issue to be resolved. Instead, the replacement she received was the same dummy handset.
Lucy tried returning it a second time, only to receive the exact same handset again.
Despite her repeated efforts to resolve the issue, Currys refused to refund her. She eventually approached her bank and managed to recover the £750 payment.
Customer Finds Bags of Rice Instead of £3,300 MacBook
The investigation also uncovered an extraordinary case involving a customer who received two bags of rice instead of an expensive Apple laptop.
Lee had spent £3,300 on a MacBook from Currys in Aldershot. Instead of finding a computer inside the package, he discovered two bags of rice.
Lee contacted Apple, which reportedly told him that the device's 12-month warranty had been activated 16 days before his purchase. However, Currys refused to reopen his complaint. Lee recovered the money through his bank, with Currys agreeing to reimburse it.
The BBC investigation also featured Andrew, who had paid £2,700 for a black MacBook but received a silver laptop bearing marks left by old stickers. Suspecting that the machine had previously been used, he contacted Currys and requested a replacement.
However, when the replacement arrived, he took it to a Currys store and filmed the package being opened. Inside was the same laptop he had returned approximately three weeks earlier.
His refund request was initially rejected. Watchdog later discovered that the laptop's warranty had been activated 19 days before Andrew bought it. He eventually received a full refund and compensation.
BBC Investigation Points to Wider Retail Fraud
The BBC investigation found similar cases across the UK, challenging the possibility that the incidents were the work of a single individual. Its findings pointed to retail fraud in which criminals switch high-value electronics for cheaper substitutes before returning the packages to retailers.
According to Watchdog, the substitutions were going undetected by Currys, which was then selling the affected products on to other customers.
High-value devices, including smartphones and laptops, are attractive targets because of the substantial difference in value between genuine products and cheaper substitutes.
The findings raise concerns about checks on returned electronics, suggesting that substituted packages could reach unsuspecting customers who have paid full price for products they never receive.
What Currys Said About the Complaints
Responding to the allegations, Currys said it served millions of customers in-store and online each year. It described cases in which customers received incorrect orders as 'exceptionally rare' and said it would investigate such incidents to ensure they were put right.
The outcomes varied across the three cases. Andrew received a full refund and compensation from Currys, while Lucy and Lee recovered their payments through their banks, with Currys agreeing to reimburse Lee's bank.
The cases raise questions about how substituted products passed through the retailer's returns process, leaving customers to pursue refunds after receiving items they had never ordered.










