
How much does Facebook really know about what's on your phone? Quite a lot, it turns out. Meta has been fined €805 million (£671 million) for accessing the photos and videos stored on millions of Android users' devices without properly obtaining their consent.
Italy's data protection agency says around 20 million Android users were affected by a feature that could access photographs, videos and associated metadata while people browsed Facebook.
What appeared to be a harmless tool designed to suggest pictures for social media posts has now raised serious questions about how much control users really have over their private files. Meta has rejected the findings and said it intends to appeal the decision.
The Facebook Feature That Could See Inside Your Phone Gallery
The controversy centres on Facebook's gallery suggestions feature, introduced in 2023. It was designed to make posting easier by recommending photographs and videos stored on a user's smartphone while they browsed the application.
However, Italy's data protection authority said the problem was how Facebook obtained permission to access that content.
The regulator says Facebook's Android app asked for access to users' photo galleries with one permission request covering the whole app. Just before it, a vague message asked users to switch on 'other features'. It never made clear that saying yes would let Facebook suggest content from their personal photos.
In other words, users could have enabled an application feature without properly understanding what else they were authorising.
Think about what's in your gallery. Family pictures, private moments, personal videos. Plenty of it was never meant for social media, and users may never want it shared publicly.
Around 20 Million Android Users Caught up in the Controversy
The scale of the issue was a major factor behind the €805 million (£671 million) penalty. About 20 million Android users. That's how many people Italy's regulator says were affected. The authority said this, along with how long the violation lasted, was a key factor in setting the fine.
Even more concerning, the authority said the infringement was still ongoing for users who had not updated their applications, as well as those who had previously given consent to the system.
That means the controversy was not simply about a feature that had existed in the past. The regulator said Meta needed to address how it operated for existing users, including those who had already agreed to its permissions.
Not Meta's First Major Privacy Battle
The Italian penalty adds to a growing list of regulatory challenges facing the social media giant over its handling of personal information.
In late October, authorities in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion (£18.9 billion) over allegations that it had misled residents for more than a decade about how their data was used.
The company criticised that decision, describing the penalty as a 'tax' on freedom of expression. The Italian authority also cited Meta's lack of cooperation during its investigation as a factor in determining the penalty.
The decision ranks among the largest fines imposed on a technology company by an Italian authority. Amazon, for comparison, received a fine exceeding €1.1 billion (£917 million) in 2021 over competition law violations, although that amount was later reduced to €752 million (£627 million) following an appeal.
For Meta, the €805 million (£671million) fine is about more than money. It is about whether users can trust what they are agreeing to when granting an app access to their phones. Your phone may be yours, but knowing who gets access to what's inside is another matter.











